RSS Twitter YouTube

RAW Myths & Facts

Introduction

RAW MythsAs the endless debate of RAW versus JPEG continues, more and more people appear to be confused as to why these two formats exist, what each is good for and when to use one or the other. First time DSLR users often wonder which format to choose and make a choice based on some random fact they heard. It does not help that a large number of incorrect information exists on the internet about the RAW and JPEG images. This feature dispels common myths encountered around the internet and in digital photography books.

Get it right in the first place is the mantra of those who advocate JPEG and Shooting JPEG is like throwing away the negative is the motto of RAW advocates. As usual, both sides are right and it is therefore very important to understand the facts before choosing sides.

RAW Myths & Facts

Myth: RAW IS AN IMAGE FILE FORMAT

False. RAW files contain data which includes some information for each pixel but not enough to represent a digital image. Even in cases that actually store full color information for each pixel, such as in cameras which use a Foveon sensor, the stored information is not in the same color-space or scale as normal computer images.

Myth: RAW IS BETTER THAN JPEG

False. RAW has advantages over JPEG but so does JPEG over RAW. There would not be so much debates on the subject if it was not! The same JPEG as the camera would produce can be obtained from a RAW file using the camera manufacturer's RAW development software or in-camera RAW conversion on select models. This means that a RAW can at least produce an image of equal image quality.

Myth: IMAGES PRODUCED FROM RAW HAVE MORE DYNAMIC RANGE

False. Once a RAW file has been converted into an image, either explicitly by someone or implicitly by an image browser, it is limited by current display technology which cannot display more dynamic range or colors than a JPEG can hold. Nearly every display in existence uses 8 bits per channel (24 bits per pixel) which is what JPEG files store. All common operating systems are also incapable of displaying more than 8-bits per channel, even for the two monitors that can support more.

Myth: RAW FILES ARE DULL AND LOW CONTRAST

False. With all the hype about RAW quality, a huge number of people's first observation about RAW is that they look bad when compared to JPEG images. They only do by accident. As mentioned earlier, a RAW file contains data not an image. Therefore when a preview is for a RAW file is shown, software must produce an image from the RAW data. If it does that poorly, which is commonly the default for many image browsers, what is shown is a poor quality image. Usually the image looks dull and has low local contrast because it shows the entire tone curve uniformly.

Myth: RAW LOOKS EXACTLY LIKE JPEG

False. Several RAW files actually include an embedded JPEG. This embedded data allows fast previews and obviously looks exactly like a JPEG. Additionally, using the default conversion from camera maker's software normally does the exact same RAW to JPEG conversion as the camera. So there are cases where the RAW is converted into the exact same JPEG. However, the benefit of RAW lies in its ability to produce different results. Shooting RAW and then using the default conversion defeats its purpose. Benefits of shooting RAW are only seen when there is time to apply different processing.

Myth: JPEG IMAGES ARE SOFT AND LACK DETAILS

False. All DSLR cameras have settings that influence sharpness and noise reduction. Manufacturers seem to believe people prefer soft images over noisy images because the defaults are often high noise-reduction and middle sharpness. Those are only defaults and most digital cameras can produce images with finely tuned characteristics. Take the time to set up your camera to produce the most pleasing images possible.

Myth: JPEG FILES HAVE HORRIBLE ARTIFACTS

False. JPEG uses something called lossy compression which means some information is removed to make the file smaller. In practice the highest quality setting affects less than 2% of pixels by less than 0.4%. The data removed is also chosen to be the least perceptible to the human visual system.

Myth: EDITING JPEG DEGRADES IMAGE QUALITY

True. Anytime a JPEG is modified and then saved, compression may reduce image quality by a tiny amount. If done repeatedly it can add up to a substantial loss of image quality. The trick used by film artists to work with lossy formats is to do all the work in a lossless format and then save back the final version in a lossy format once all the work is done. Therefore it is better to do repetitive edits in PNG, TIFF or PSD and then save a final JPEG for printing or online use.

Myth: SHOOTING JPEG WITH A DSLR IS LIKE USING A POINT & SHOOT

False. DSLR cameras have a huge number of advantages over point & shoot digital cameras, including higher image quality and speed. Even DSLRs tend to shoot longer continuously in JPEG than in RAW.

Myth: REAL PHOTOGRAPHERS SHOOT RAW

False. The professional industry is just as divided on the subject as everyone else. They are pros that exclusively shoot JPEG, ones that exclusively shoot RAW, ones that always shoot JPEG+RAW and ones that use each format part of the time.

Myth: DNG IS A NON PROPRIETARY RAW FORMAT

DNGFalse. DNG belongs to Adobe. Adobe grants a license to use its patents to those who wish to use the DNG file format. While it is not owned by any camera manufacturer, it remains a file format that belongs to profit oriented corporation.

One of the reasons for DNG is to have a standard format that can be processed by future software long after the camera maker stops making a particular camera or goes out of business. While with is true in principal, the interpretation of the sensor data is specific to each camera and therefore that knowledge must be built in somewhere and kept up to date with new generations of software for legacy support. The one hope for longevity is to process RAW to a commonly understood DNG interpretation. Adobe covers part of what is needed for that in its 2009 DNG update which supports embedded profiles.

Myth: DNG CAN STORE RAW DATA FROM ANY DIGITAL CAMERA

True today. The DNG format was updated in 2009 to make sure it can hold the data produced by any current digital camera. It does contain special information to treat the information differently if it comes from a Fuji SuperCCD since the arrangement of pixels is different than conventional images. If other new technologies appear that does not fit the current DNG mold, Adobe has to change the DNG format to support those as well. Therefore more than one type of DNG files will exist and software will have to cope with the difference, just like they have to cope with different RAW formats.

Neocamera Blog is a medium for expressing ideas related to digital cameras and photography. Read about digital cameras in the context of technology, media, art and the world. Latest posts links:

Camera Bag

Clear

Your camera bag is empty. To add a camera or lens click on the star next to its name.

Your camera bag is empty.

Add cameras or lenses by clicking on the star next to their name.

Updates

    2017.11.10

  • 2017.11.10

    Best Digital Cameras of 2017

    Best Digital Cameras of 2017

    The Best Cameras of 2017 awarded by Neocamera: Best Travel-Zoom, Best Premium Compact, Best Ultra-Zoom, Best Mirrorless (Beginner, Advanced and Professional) and Best DSLR (Entry, Enthusiast and Professional), now including budget choices.

  • 2017.11.07

  • 2017.11.07

    MindShift Photocross 13 Review

    MindShift Photocross 13 Review

    Review of the Mindshift Photocross 13 Sling Bag.

  • 2017.11.01

  • 2017.11.01

    Fujifilm X-E3 Review

    Fujifilm X-E3 Review

    Unique Fujifilm rangefinder-styled mirrorless. 24 MP APS-C X-Trans CMOS III sensor with built-in 325-Point Hybrid AF system and X-Processor Pro. 14 FPS Drive with Electronic-Shutter or 8 FPS with Mechanical Shutter. 4K Ultra-HD Video at 30 FPS. Highly compact body with a builtin 2.4 MP 0.39" LCD with Eye-Start Sensor, 0.62X magnification and 100% coverage and 3" Touchscreen 1 MP LCD plus dual control-dials.

  • 2017.10.16

  • 2017.10.16

    Panasonic Lumix GX850 Review

    Panasonic Lumix GX850 Review

    Highly compact mirrorless with 16 MP Four-Thirds CMOS sensor capable of 4K Ultra-HD video. Fast 10 FPS drive and 1/16000s-60s hybrid shutter. 4K Output for 30 FPS bursts, Post Focus and built-in Focus Stacking.

  • 2017.10.07

  • 2017.10.07

    Olympus OM-D E-M1 Mark II Review

    Olympus OM-D E-M1 Mark II Review

    Olympus professional Micro Four-Thirds mirrorless with 20 MP sensor, built-in 5-axis Image-Stabilization, 121-Point Phase-Detect and Contrast Detect AF, 60 FPS Drive, 18 FPS with Continuous AF, Ultra-HD and Cinema 4K Video. Large built-in 2.4 MP 0.45" EVF with 100% Coverage, 0.74X magnification and Eye-Start Sensor in a freezeproof and weatherproof body with dual control-dials.

  • 2017.09.06

  • 2017.09.06

    Fujifilm GFX-50S In-Depth Review

    Fujifilm GFX-50S In-Depth Review

    In-depth review of the Fujifilm GFX-50S Medium Format Mirrorless Digital Camera, a groundbreaking 50 megapixels camera with large 44x33mm sensor and unique modular EVF system. ISO 50-102400 range, 3 FPS drive and 1080p video.

  • 2017.08.23

  • 2017.08.23

    Fujinon GFX Lens Roundup

    Fujinon GFX Lens Roundup

    Roundup of reviews for GFX Medium Format Mirrorless lenses: Fujinon GF 23mm F/4R LM WR, GF 32-64mm F/4R LM WR and GF 110mm F/2R LM WR.

  • 2017.08.14

  • 2017.08.14

    Nikon D500 Review

    Nikon D500 Review

    Full-review of the ultimate Nikon flagship APS-C DSLR. The Nikon D500 offers a new 20 MP CMOS sensor with incredible ISO 50-1638400, 10 FPS, 4K Ultra-HD and a 153-Point Phase-Detect AF system sensitive to -4 EV. Built for professionals into a weatherproof body with dual control-dials and large 100% coverage viewfinder with built-in shutter.

  • 2016.12.13

  • 2016.12.13

    DxO ViewPoint 3 Review

    DxO ViewPoint 3 Review

    Review of DxO ViewPoint 3. Perspective, distortion and horizon correction software.

  • 2016.08.25

  • 2016.08.25

    Nikon D5 XQD Review

    Nikon D5 XQD Review

    Nikon flagship professional DSLR with 20 megapixels Full-Frame CMOS sensor. All-new 153-point Phase-Detect AF sensitive to -4 EV. ISO 50 to unprecedented 3,276,800! 12 FPS Drive for 200 JPEGs or 180 RAW. First Nikon DSLR with 4K Ultra HD video.