State of the Art - Ultra-Compact vs Digital SLR
News
2007.11.06
Every once in a while, it is fun to compare completely different things just to see where they are relative to each other. Among digital cameras, we have the ultra-compact models on one end of the spectrum and the digital SLRs on at the opposite end. For former are designed to provide good-enough image quality in the smallest package possible, the latter as designed to be uncompromising and produce the best image quality.
Technologically, DSLR cameras have a serious advantage over much smaller camera: Size. Specifically, the size of their image-sensors. Larger image sensors have an advantage because of their greater surface area which can gather more light. Considering image quality alone, no matter what we can obtain with a small sensor, we can also go better with a larger one. Basically, whatever technology exists to make the best sensor for an ultra-compact, the same technology could be used to make a sensor for a DSLR. If the number of pixels remains unchanged, the DSLR will have larger pixels and therefore its images which show less noise and greater dynamic range. Well, I'm over-simplifying a little, but not by much.
So here we go again, we have another silly pointless comparison between one of the latest ultra-compact digital cameras and one of the latest DSLR cameras. For those who missed it, we did this before in the full review of the Fuji Finepix F30. As we saw in that comparison, the F30 turned in quite an impressive performance if we ignore the sharpening artifacts. Here are unmodified 100% crops of matching ISO of the Fuji Finepix F50SE and the Sony Alpha A700. Results are discussed below.
Fuji Finepix F50SE | Sony Alpha A700 |
ISO 100 | |
ISO 400 | |
ISO 1600 |
It is easy to see that the colors are not the same between the two cameras. Both were set on automatic white-balance, both on auto-exposure, taking pictures of the same scene under the same lights. Neither of them reproduced the true colors, but the Fuji Finepix F50SE did much better. For reasons I do not understand yet, DSLRs get the white-balance of incandescent lights more wrong. Perhaps fixed-lens cameras can read more sample-points when computing white-balance because they can read any point of the sensor, while DSLRs have to rely on a dedicated sensor which provides less sample points. Note to self: investigate this further.
In this comparison, the advantage of the ultra-compact seems to stop at better white-balance. Even at ISO 100, the Alpha shows a slightly sharper and smoother image. Although it cannot be seen in these crops, this scene has more contrast then either sensor can capture. The rendition of overall tonalities favor greatly the DSLR which clipped less highlights.
At higher ISO, the DSLR leaves the ultra-compact in the dust. Noise levels increase much more rapidly with the F50 than with the A700. Although both cameras keep a relatively good amount of sharpness across ISO, the Sony Alpha A700 still produces a usable ISO 1600 while the F50's equivalent crop is a mess.
The final word is that current digital SLRs produce images with much less noise and better sharpness when equipped with a good lens than ultra-compact cameras. Not only that, this image quality gap has apparently increased in the last few years. This can only be explained by the rapid expansion in resolution among fixed-lens cameras. Do not forget that differences between DSLR cameras and ultra-compacts are numerous, image quality is just one of them.
- Digital Camera
- Technology
Please Support Neocamera
All information on Neocamera is provided free of charge yet running this website is a huge endeavor. Purchases made via affiliate links found throughout the site help keep it running and up-to-date. There is no additional cost to you, so please consider buying via these links to our affilates:
If you found any information on this site valuable and did not purchase via our affiliate links, please considering donating via PayPal:
Any amount will be greatly appreaciated. Thank you for your support!
New Cameras & Lenses
Sony FE 16-25mm F/2.8G
Weatherproof
Sony E Mount Zoom
2024-04-16Tamron Di III 28-75mm F/2.8 VXD G2
Weatherproof
Nikon Z Mount Zoom
2024-03-28Sigma A 50mm F/1.2 DG DN
Weatherproof
Sony E Mount Prime Lens
2024-03-27Sigma A 50mm F/1.2 DG DN
Weatherproof
Leica L Mount Prime Lens
2024-03-27Nikkor Z 28-400mm F/4-8 VR
Stabilization & Weatherproof
Nikon Z Mount Zoom
2024-03-27Leica SL3
60 Megapixels Mirrorless
Leica L Lens Mount
Built-in Stabilization
Weatherproof down to -10C
2024-03-07
Updates
2024.04.03
Fujifilm X-T5 Review
Newest Fujifilm flagship boasting a 40 MP APS-C sensor, 5-axis IBIS with 7-stop efficiency, 15 FPS continuous drive, 6.2K Video capture, dual control-dials and dual SDXC UHS-II slots in a sturdy weatherproof and freezeproof body.
2023.11.20
Best Digital Cameras of 2023
Find out which are the Best Digital Cameras of 2023. All the new Mirrorless Digital Cameras from entry-level to high-end professional.
2023.07.10
Fujifilm X-H2 Review
40 Megapixels APS-C Hybrid Mirrorless Digital Camera with 7-stop IBIS. Fastest shutter ever and 8K video capture. Large builtin EVF with 0.8X magnification and 5.8 MP, plus an Eye-Start Sensor. Packed with features and large number of controls in a weatherproof and freezeproof body.
2023.05.07
Sony FE 20-70mm F/4G Review
Review of the unique Sony FE 20-70mm F/4G lens. The optical zoom of this lens spans ultra-wide-angle and medium focal-length coverage, making it one of the most versatile Full-Frame lenses on the market.
2023.01.15
Huion Inspiroy Dial 2 Review
Review of the Huion Inspiroy Dial 2 tablet, a medium sized drawing surface with dual dials and customizable buttons. Connects via USB-C or Bluetooth 5.0 with Windows, Linux and Android support.
2022.12.08
How to Pack for a Photo Trip
Find out how to pack for a travel photography trip, carry your gear safely while meeting airline regulations.
2022.11.13
Best Digital Cameras of 2022
The best digital cameras of 2022. A short list of the most outstanding models in their respective categories. Choose one for yourself or as a gift.
2022.09.21
Pentax DA* 60-250mm F/4 SDM Review
Review of the Pentax DA* 60-250mm F/4 SDM, the constant-aperture telephoto zoom with the highest zoom-ratio on the market.
2022.09.20
Pentax DA* 50-135mm F/2.8 SDM Review
Review of the Pentax DA* 50-135mm F/2.8 SDM, the lightest professional telephoto zoom native to the K-mount.
2022.09.10
Pentax DA* 11-18mm F/2.8 DC AW Review
Review of the Pentax DA* 11-18mm F/2.8 DC AW, the widest professional ultra-wide zoom native to the K-mount.
2021.11.24
50 Gifts Under $50 For Photographers in 2021
50 Gifts photographers will love. All for under $50 USD. 2021 Edition.
2021.11.17
Best Digital Cameras for 2021
Neocamera shows which are the very best Digital Cameras for 2021 in every category: Mirrorless, DSLR, Premium Compact, Ultra-Zoom and Rugged.