What's Wrong With EXIF?

News

2010.01.29

EXIF is the format used to store information in a digital image. Photographer really appreciate having that information as it tells them what settings they used to take a picture, information such as the camera model, focal-length, f-stop, shutter-speed, ISO and much more. Most modern image viewers such as PMView Pro of Geeqie have an easy way to show EXIF data. EXIF is a relatively old standard, technologically speaking, with version 2.2 published in 2002.

IDImager Camera MakersGiven the standard's age, one would think that every recent imaging software would know how to handle it properly. Yet most catalogging software get something wrong. On the right is example from IDImager. Notice how there are 2 Nikons, 4 Pentax and 3 Sony makes? Intuitively you would think that perhaps a camera produces EXIF info spelled slightly differently (as in Pentax vs Pentax Corporation) or some have spaces after the name and therefore it would appear under one maker or another. However, Bibble Pro confuses things further by trying to group camera models under their makers and things get even more silly because of that. For example, it shows the same camera model under two different brands, like the Pentax K20D which appears under PENTAX and under PENTAX Corporation. What the heck?

Another piece of information found among EXIF data is an identifier for the lens used. This identifier does not seem to be the actual lens info but some kind of number which has to be translated into a particular lens model. It appears that Bibble Pro guesses instead of using that information as it produces a catalog with a huge list of lenses, some of them I did not even know existed. It seems to also do that every time, so even if it would guess correctly that a photo was taken with the Canon 70-200mm F4 for example, another photo taken from the same lens may appear as taken with the Canon 200mm F1.8. Very strange.

At first glance, Lightroom seems reasonable with no confusion of makes and models, although it does not try to group them. The list of lens contains one entry called Unknown Lens which references about half my photo collection. However one lens was clearly substituted for another to the point of absurdity where Lightroom reports I used a Pentax F28-80mm F3.5-4.5 at 24mm! Ooops.

IDImager gets shows a long list of lenses. Some lenses are the actual ones I used, such as a EF 50mm F1.4 USM, some are the wrong lens such as the Sigma 18-125mm F3.5-5.6 (with several pictures taken with it at F/2.8), and some are listed as a set of 4 numbers, like an IP address (0,0,226,8). Initially I thought that, instead of grouping unrecognized lenses into an Unknown Lens category like Lightroom, it simply marked them using the lens identifier. After a closer look I saw that pictures taken with some lenses, for example the DA* 50-135mm F2.8 sometimes appeared associated with the right lens and sometimes appeared associated with lens 0,0,241,8.

If someone can explain this, I'd really like to know what is going on here.


  • Digital Photography
More

Please Support Neocamera

All information on Neocamera is provided free of charge yet running this website is a huge endeavor. Purchases made via affiliate links found throughout the site help keep it running and up-to-date. There is no additional cost to you, so please consider buying via these links to our affilates:

  • Photography Store Banner
  • Adorama Banner
  • Essential Photo Banner
  • BH Photo Banner

If you found any information on this site valuable and did not purchase via our affiliate links, please considering donating via PayPal:

Any amount will be greatly appreaciated. Thank you for your support!

New Cameras & Lenses

Camera Bag

Clear

Your camera bag is empty. To add a camera or lens click on the star next to its name.

Your camera bag is empty.

Add cameras or lenses by clicking on the star next to their name.

Updates

    2024.04.03

  • 2024.04.03

    Fujifilm X-T5 Review Update Poster

    Fujifilm X-T5 Review

    Newest Fujifilm flagship boasting a 40 MP APS-C sensor, 5-axis IBIS with 7-stop efficiency, 15 FPS continuous drive, 6.2K Video capture, dual control-dials and dual SDXC UHS-II slots in a sturdy weatherproof and freezeproof body.

  • 2023.11.20

  • 2023.11.20

    Best Digital Cameras of 2023 Update Poster

    Best Digital Cameras of 2023

    Find out which are the Best Digital Cameras of 2023. All the new Mirrorless Digital Cameras from entry-level to high-end professional.

  • 2023.07.10

  • 2023.07.10

    Fujifilm X-H2 Review Update Poster

    Fujifilm X-H2 Review

    40 Megapixels APS-C Hybrid Mirrorless Digital Camera with 7-stop IBIS. Fastest shutter ever and 8K video capture. Large builtin EVF with 0.8X magnification and 5.8 MP, plus an Eye-Start Sensor. Packed with features and large number of controls in a weatherproof and freezeproof body.

  • 2023.05.07

  • 2023.05.07

    Sony FE 20-70mm F/4G Review Update Poster

    Sony FE 20-70mm F/4G Review

    Review of the unique Sony FE 20-70mm F/4G lens. The optical zoom of this lens spans ultra-wide-angle and medium focal-length coverage, making it one of the most versatile Full-Frame lenses on the market.

  • 2023.01.15

  • 2023.01.15

    Huion Inspiroy Dial 2 Review Update Poster

    Huion Inspiroy Dial 2 Review

    Review of the Huion Inspiroy Dial 2 tablet, a medium sized drawing surface with dual dials and customizable buttons. Connects via USB-C or Bluetooth 5.0 with Windows, Linux and Android support.

  • 2022.12.08

  • 2022.12.08

    How to Pack for a Photo Trip Update Poster

    How to Pack for a Photo Trip

    Find out how to pack for a travel photography trip, carry your gear safely while meeting airline regulations.

  • 2022.11.13

  • 2022.11.13

    Best Digital Cameras of 2022 Update Poster

    Best Digital Cameras of 2022

    The best digital cameras of 2022. A short list of the most outstanding models in their respective categories. Choose one for yourself or as a gift.

  • 2022.09.21

  • 2022.09.21

    Pentax DA* 60-250mm F/4 SDM Review Update Poster

    Pentax DA* 60-250mm F/4 SDM Review

    Review of the Pentax DA* 60-250mm F/4 SDM, the constant-aperture telephoto zoom with the highest zoom-ratio on the market.

  • 2022.09.20

  • 2022.09.20

    Pentax DA* 50-135mm F/2.8 SDM Review Update Poster

    Pentax DA* 50-135mm F/2.8 SDM Review

    Review of the Pentax DA* 50-135mm F/2.8 SDM, the lightest professional telephoto zoom native to the K-mount.

  • 2022.09.10

  • 2022.09.10

    Pentax DA* 11-18mm F/2.8 DC AW Review Update Poster

    Pentax DA* 11-18mm F/2.8 DC AW Review

    Review of the Pentax DA* 11-18mm F/2.8 DC AW, the widest professional ultra-wide zoom native to the K-mount.

  • 2021.11.24

  • 2021.11.24

    50 Gifts Under $50 For Photographers in 2021 Update Poster

    50 Gifts Under $50 For Photographers in 2021

    50 Gifts photographers will love. All for under $50 USD. 2021 Edition.

  • 2021.11.17

  • 2021.11.17

    Best Digital Cameras for 2021 Update Poster

    Best Digital Cameras for 2021

    Neocamera shows which are the very best Digital Cameras for 2021 in every category: Mirrorless, DSLR, Premium Compact, Ultra-Zoom and Rugged.