This book is very difficult to describe as a whole because its parts vary in
quality and accuracy. What unifies this book is its writing style. Indeed, most
explanations are simple and are supported by several examples.
Part 1 of this book serves as an overview to digital photography. In many
more words than necessary, it covers digital cameras, imaging software, photo
fixing and image storage. This very basic part diverges frequently with
many irrelevant anecdotes. Furthermore, this part is quite vague and does not
provide much information not found in the rest of the book.
Digital photography equipment is explained in part 2 of the book. Digital
cameras are introduced based on features and pricing here. This part also
explains the basic modes of digital cameras (program mode, aperture priority,
shutter priority and manual mode) and common controls (ISO, metering and exposure
compensation). While this part starts off well, the second half of it is full
of errors and outdated information. In particular, one page mentions that EXIF
is an image format, another has the relative pricing of flash memory and microdrives
wrong, at least one reason for choosing a DSLR is false, the discussion of PC
vs. Mac is inaccurate, the chapter on computer hardware is full of mistakes and
the discussion on monitor dot-pitch is so oversimplified it is useless. While
technological advancements constantly improve hardware, a lot of information
in this chapter has never been true. On the other hand, printers, scanners
and photographic accessories are well explained. Surprisingly the section
on scanners is among the best in the entire book.
Taking Great Pictures, part 3 of Digital Photography - All-in-one
desk reference -For dummies should have been its own book. After an unimpressive
start, this part unexpectedly stood out. Its first chapter, explains photographic
composition in details with many comparative examples and interesting observations.
Composition is inherently a difficult subject to tackle due to its creative nature,
but the Taking Great Pictures does it admirably well. The remainder of part 3, specifically
covers different types of subjects such as close-ups, people, sports, action
and travel photography. For each type of subject, equipment, composition
and technique is discussed separately. Humor is used to keep readers interested
while intricate details are explained to educate advanced hobbyists. Advanced
topics include lighting, shooting for publications, publishing resources, product
photography, painting with light, panoramas and adventure photography. Only
two things about this part don't impress: the amount of repetition and the photographic
examples. Perhaps, the latter is done purposefully not to intimidate beginning
photographers.
|
Part 4 covers basic image
editing. This is another good part of the book
which covers its topic well. This part starts off by separating the possible
from the impossible using image editing. Common image problems are then explained
with examples and brief solutions. Having read other books on the topic,
it was easy to appreciate that most explanations in this chapter do not depend
on a specific imaging software. The final chapter of this part introduces various
imaging software and how to chose between them. This is also something
seldom seen since most books just focus on a single software from Adobe.
Photoshop and Photoshop Elements specifically are covered in part 5. This
part is relatively short but serves well as an introduction to these two applications. The
differences between these applications can be found scattered through the three
chapters. Strangely, the book starts by explaining what is new to these
software since the previous versions. It is unclear wether the target audience
for this book would find that information useful.
Part 6 covers the topic of restoring old photos in details. While
it is roughly as short as the previous part, it covers the topic reasonably well
and even has room to repeat some stuff (dodging and burning for example) from
the previous two parts. Finally, part 7 covers printing and sharing images.
This particular part is the shortest of all and contains surprisingly little
information even for its length.
Overall, this book is less than half-full (or more than half-empty) with pertinent
and accurate information. It feels like its been written by someone who knows
photography, someone who knows imaging software and someone who knows scanners.
Those topics are indeed well covered, but they could still have been covered
more concisely. Anyone who has this book already should concentrate on
its better parts. Others can find better value elsewhere.

|